Ogni anno una giuria che rappresenta tutti gli aspetti dell'industria del fumetto seleziona i candidati ai Will Eisner Comic Industry Awards. Ecco le persone che hanno ricoperto il ruolo di giudici a partire dal 1992.

---

Premi Eisner 2023

• Moni Barrette
• Peter Jones
• Jen King
• Sean Kleefeld
• A. David Lewis
• TJ Shevlin

---

2022 Premi Eisner

• Barbara Kesel
• Kim Munson
• Rik Offenberger
• Jameson Rohrer
• Jessica Tseang
• Aaron Trites

---

Premi Eisner 2021

• Marco Davanzo
• Shelley Fruchey
• Pamela Jackson
• Keithan Jones
• Alonso Nunez
• Jim Thompson

---

Premi Eisner 2020

• Martha Cornog
• Jamie Coville
• Michael Dooley
• Alex Grecian
• Simon Jimenez
• Laura O'Meara

---

Premi Eisner 2019

• Chris Arrant
• Jared Gardner
• Traci Glass
• Jenn Haines
• Steve Howearth
• Jimmie Robinson

---

Premi Eisner 2018

• Candice Mack
• Graeme McMillan
• Tate Ottati
• Nhora Serrano
• Alexander Simmons
• Bill Wilson

---

Premi Eisner 2017

• Alan Campbell
• Rob Clough
• Jamie Newbold
• Robert Peaslee
• Dawn Rutherford
• Martha Thomases

---

Premi Eisner 2016

• Brian Doherty
• Danny Fingeroth
• Jason Grazulis
• Jason Poole
• Natalie Powell
• Carol Tilley

---

Premi Eisner 2015

• Carr DeAngelo
• Richard Graham
• Sean Howe
• Susan Kirtley
• Ron McFee
• Maggie Thompson

---

Premi Eisner 2014

• Kathy Bottarini
• William H. Foster
• Christian Lipski
• Lee Oeth
• Jenny Robb
• James Romberger

---

Premi Eisner 2013

• Michael Cavna
• Charles Hatfield
• Adam Healy
• Dott.ssa Katie Monnin
• Frank Santoro
• John Smith

---

Premi Eisner 2012

• Brigid Alverson
• Calum Johnston
• Jesse Karp
• Larry Marder
• Benjamin Saunders
• Mary Sturhann

---

Premi Eisner 2011

• John Berry
• Ned Cato Jr.
• Karen Green
• Andrew Helfer
• Rich Johnson
• Chris Powell

---

Premi Eisner 2010

• Craig Fischer
• Francesca Goldsmith
• John Hogan
• James Hudnall
• Wayne Winsett

---

Premi Eisner 2009

• Amanda Emmert
• Mike Pawuk
• John Shableski
• Ben Towle
• Andrew Wheeler

---

Premi Eisner 2008

• John Davis
• Paul DiFilippo
• Atomo! Freeman
• Jeff Jensen
• Eva Volin

---

Premi Eisner 2007

• Robin Brenner
• Whitney Matheson
• Chris Reilly
• Giacomo Sime
• Jeff Vander Meer

---

Premi Eisner 2006

• Christopher Allen
• John Gallagher
• Nisha Gopalan
• Robert Randle
• Robert Scott

---

Premi Eisner 2005

• Gib Bickel
• Steve Conley
• Kat Kan
• Tom McLean
• Tom Russo

---

Premi Eisner 2004

• Greg Bennett
• Marc Bernardin
• Meloney Crawford Chadwick
• Andrew Farago
• Filip Sablik

---

Premi Eisner 2003

• Andrew Arnold
• Jen Contino
• Steve Leaf
• Jeremy Shorr
• Charles Vess

---

Premi Eisner 2002

• Matt Lehman
• Lee Marrs
• Greg McElhatton
• Calvin Reid
• Tim Stroup

---

Premi Eisner 2001

• Anina Bennett
• Karon Flage
• Ralph Mathieu
• Chris Schaff
• Douglas Wolk

---

Premio Eisner 2000

• Alex Amado
• Joe Ferrara
• Brian Saner Lamken
• Wayne Markley
• Pam Noles

---

Premi Eisner 1999

• Jon Cohen
• Mike Schimmel
• Len Strazewski
• Nancy Trempe
• Jonah Weiland

---

Premi Eisner 1998

• Frank Alison
• Steve Bissette
• Josh Braun
• Eric Kirsammer
• Beth Rimmels

---

Premi Eisner 1997

• Joe Field
• Paul Grant
• Janet Hetherington
• Tony Isabella
• Jesse Leon McCann

---

Premi Eisner 1996

• Tom DeHaven
• Nancy Ford
• Mark Herr
• Frank Kurtz
• Rory Root

---

Premi Eisner 1995

• Carl Denbow
• Tom Fassbender
• Joyce Greenholdt
• Larry Houston
• Chris Sturhann

---

Premi Eisner 1994

• Mark Askwith
• Mimi Cruz
• Michael T. Gilbert
• Barry Short
• Mark Yturralde

---

Premi Eisner 1993

• Brian Hibbs
• Rolf Holbach
• Beth Holley
• Heidi MacDonald
• Arlen Schumer

---

Premi Eisner 1992

• Jeff Gelb
• Rochon Perry
• Lynn Peterson
• Scott Shaw!
• Janet Tait